Pore Polish: Mandelic, Glycolic, or Lactic — Which Smooths Without the Ouch?
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases—at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I truly believe in.
If you’ve ever dabbled with chemical exfoliants, you know it can feel like skincare roulette: one night you’re glowing, the next you’re peeling like a croissant. Enter the alpha-hydroxy acids (AHAs) — the family of water-soluble exfoliators that can polish away dullness and refine pores. But here’s the thing: not all acids are created equal. Pick the wrong one and your barrier waves the white flag. Pick the right one and you get smoother, brighter skin without the drama. Today we’re putting three fan-favorites under the microscope — mandelic, glycolic, and lactic acid — to see which one actually smooths without the ouch (and yes, I’ve got the science receipts to back it up).
Meet the Pore-Polishing Trio
All three of our contenders — mandelic, glycolic, and lactic — belong to the alpha-hydroxy acid (AHA) family. That means they’re water-soluble exfoliators that loosen the “glue” holding dead skin cells together, helping them shed more easily. The result? Smoother skin texture, fewer clogged pores, and a brighter glow.
Clinical research shows AHAs don’t just resurface skin — they can also boost collagen production and improve uneven pigmentation over time (Sharad, 2013; Lee & Oh, 2023). In other words, they’re multitaskers. But here’s the catch: the way each acid behaves on your skin depends on its molecular size, penetration depth, and natural side-benefits. That’s why choosing the right one for your skin type makes all the difference.
Mandelic Acid — The Gentle Giant
If glycolic acid is the over-caffeinated extrovert of the AHA family, mandelic is its chill older cousin. Thanks to its larger molecular size, mandelic penetrates skin more slowly than other acids — which means it’s far less likely to sting, burn, or leave you looking like a tomato.
Science backs up its “gentle but effective” reputation. Clinical trials have shown mandelic acid reduces acne lesions and pigmentation with significantly lower irritation compared to glycolic acid (Arch Dermatol Res, 2010). It’s especially useful for people with sensitive skin, darker skin tones that are prone to post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, or anyone who wants steady progress without the ouch.
Think of mandelic as the entry-level exfoliant that still gets results. It won’t bulldoze through dead skin cells overnight, but with consistent use, it polishes away dullness and keeps pores clearer — minus the angry red aftermath.
By Wishtrend Mandelic Acid 5% — gentle starter formula that tackles acne and pigmentation without irritation.
👉 Check price on Amazon
Allies of Skin Mandelic Pigmentation Corrector — luxe serum that brightens uneven tone and softens stubborn dark spots.
👉 Check price on Amazon
The Ordinary Mandelic Acid 10% — affordable, effective upgrade for sensitive skin users ready for a little more power.
👉 Check price on Amazon
Glycolic Acid — The Power Player
If mandelic is the gentle cousin, glycolic is the overachiever who wants extra credit. It has the smallest molecular size of all the AHAs, which means it zips into the skin quickly and works hard to unglue dead cells. That makes it one of the most effective acids for refining texture, fading hyperpigmentation, and giving skin a legit glow.
The science is stacked: glycolic acid peels and treatments have been shown to improve acne, boost collagen production, and reduce the appearance of enlarged pores (Wang et al., 1997; Sharad, 2013). Basically, if you want fast, visible results, glycolic delivers.
The trade-off? It can be irritating, especially for sensitive or dry skin types. Think tingling, redness, or even a compromised barrier if you go too hard, too fast. Glycolic works best for those with resilient, oily, or thicker skin that can handle its intensity — or for seasoned acid users who know their skin’s limits.
Pixi Glow Tonic (5% Glycolic) — drugstore legend for glow that gently resurfaces and brightens.
👉 Check price on Amazon
The Ordinary Glycolic Acid 7% Toning Solution — budget-friendly powerhouse that evens tone and refines texture.
👉 Check price on Amazon
Drunk Elephant T.L.C. Framboos Glycolic Night Serum — premium AHA blend for serious smoothing and radiance.
👉 Check price on Amazon
Lactic Acid — The Barrier Buddy
Lactic acid is like the happy medium between mandelic and glycolic. Its molecular size sits in the middle, so it exfoliates effectively but without quite as much drama as glycolic. Bonus: lactic is also a natural component of your skin’s own moisturizing factors, which means it pulls double duty — smoothing texture and boosting hydration.
Clinical studies show lactic acid improves both skin hydration and exfoliation, making it a great option for dry, dull, or combination skin that needs polish without tightness (Măgerușan et al., 2023). Think of it as an acid with built-in kindness.
If your skin gets cranky with glycolic but mandelic feels a little too slow, lactic acid hits the sweet spot: enough exfoliation to smooth pores and fine lines, but gentle enough to keep your barrier happy.
Biossance Squalane + Lactic Acid Resurfacing Night Serum — barrier-friendly formula that hydrates while gently resurfacing.
👉 Check price on Amazon
The Ordinary Lactic Acid 5% + HA — gentle, hydrating starter acid that smooths without stripping.
👉 Check price on Amazon
Sunday Riley Good Genes Lactic Acid Treatment — luxe exfoliant that plumps fine lines and evens tone.
👉 Check price on Amazon
How to Choose Your AHA (Without Wrecking Your Barrier)
So, which of these three should get VIP status in your routine? The answer depends less on hype and more on your skin’s vibe:
Sensitive, acne-prone, or darker skin tones? Go for mandelic. Its larger molecule makes it less irritating and safer for post-inflammatory marks.
Dry or combo skin craving hydration? Lactic is your sweet spot — it exfoliates while pulling in moisture.
Resilient, oily, or thick skin? Glycolic is your powerhouse, delivering faster results in texture and pore refinement.
No matter which you choose, here are the ground rules: start 1–3 nights per week, always follow with moisturizer, and never skip sunscreen the next morning. Over-exfoliation is a straight ticket to barrier damage — and no glow is worth that.
Quick FAQ
Q: Can I layer AHAs together?
Not unless you enjoy living on the edge of irritation. Stick to one AHA at a time — your skin doesn’t need a cocktail of acids to exfoliate effectively.
Q: How long until I see results?
Most studies show visible smoothness and radiance within 4–6 weeks of consistent use. Translation: give it time before declaring your acid a flop.
Q: Can I use AHAs with retinoids?
Not in the same routine (unless you’re advanced and your barrier is basically bulletproof). A good split is AHAs on alternate nights and retinoids on the others.
Q: Do I still need sunscreen if I’m using acids at night?
Yes, yes, and yes. AHAs make your skin more sensitive to UV damage. Skipping SPF the next morning is like wearing a raincoat but leaving the hood down — you’re still getting soaked.
Final Takeaway
There’s no one-size-fits-all “best” AHA — it all comes down to your skin’s personality. Sensitive or acne-prone? Mandelic has your back. Dry or combo? Lactic will smooth and hydrate without the sting. Oily or resilient? Glycolic gets results fast, as long as you respect its strength. What science shows clearly is that all three can refine texture, brighten skin, and make pores look less obvious — when used consistently and paired with sunscreen. The key is choosing the one that works with your skin, not against it.
Want to dig deeper?
Curious about other science-backed ways to refine pores? This guide breaks down the top 5 ingredients proven to work.
Wondering which toners deliver acids in gentler formats? Here are the ones backed by evidence.
Not sure if AHAs or BHAs are your best match? This post covers the best BHA exfoliants for clogged pores.
Looking for a non-exfoliant pore helper? Here’s the science on niacinamide and how long it takes to show results.
References
- Sharad J. “Glycolic acid peel therapy – a current review.” Clin Cosmet Investig Dermatol. 2013;6:281–288.
- Lee DH, Oh IY. “Effects of alpha-hydroxy acids on photoaged skin: a review.” Arch Plast Surg. 2023;50(1):5–12.
- Wang CM, et al. “The treatment of acne with glycolic acid.” Dermatol Surg. 1997;23(1):23–29.
- Rendl M, et al. “Topical use of mandelic acid in the treatment of acne vulgaris.” Arch Dermatol Res. 2010;302(8):599–604.
- Măgerușan L, et al. “Lactic acid as a cosmetic ingredient: benefits and applications.” Farmacia. 2023;71(2):345–352.
