🧼 Cystic Acne vs. Hormonal Acne vs. Fungal Acne: How to Tell the Difference (And Treat It, Fast)

Acne & Breakouts
Written By Mollie Kelly Tufman
acne-treatments-thoughtful-woman-pink-background

This post contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases—at no extra cost to you. I only recommend products I truly believe in.

Not All Acne Is Created Equal

You’re religiously double-cleansing, patting in your niacinamide, and even gave up dairy (RIP cheese boards)... so why is your skin still breaking out? Before you rage-toss your skincare stash, here’s a plot twist: not all breakouts are the same—and if you’re treating the wrong kind of acne, you might actually be making things worse.

Enter the triple threat: cystic acne, hormonal acne, and fungal acne. They all bring the drama, but they do it in very different ways—and trust me, your salicylic acid can’t fight every battle.

This post is your skin’s new BFF intervention. We’re diving deep into what makes each type unique, how to tell them apart like a skincare detective, and most importantly, how to treat each one correctly using peer-reviewed science—not TikTok trends.

No more guessing, no more wasted products, no more attacking fungal breakouts with retinol and wondering why it’s not helping. Let’s decode what your breakouts are really trying to tell you—and find out how to shut them up, fast.

🧪 The Science of Acne: What Causes Each Type?

Let’s get one thing straight: not all breakouts are created equal—and neither are their root causes. Before you reach for your entire skincare arsenal, it's worth understanding why these zits are popping up in the first place. Spoiler: the difference between a painful chin cyst and a forehead full of tiny bumps might be bacterial vs. hormonal vs. fungal... and if you treat the wrong one? You might actually make it worse.

Cystic Acne:

This is the boss-level breakout. Cystic acne forms when your pores get clogged deep down with oil, dead skin cells, and Cutibacterium acnes bacteria (formerly Propionibacterium—because science loves a rename). Your immune system freaks out, inflammation kicks in, and bam: painful, red, under-the-skin monsters that can last for weeks.

Hormonal Acne:

Blame your hormones. (No, seriously.) Androgens like testosterone ramp up your skin’s oil production, especially during your period, puberty, pregnancy, or high-stress weeks. This excess oil clogs pores and leads to breakouts that always seem to show up in the same spots—usually your jawline, chin, and around your mouth. You’ll know it when you see it: red, inflamed, and deeply committed to ruining your week.

Fungal Acne (Malassezia folliculitis):

Plot twist: this one’s not actually acne at all. It’s a yeast overgrowth in your hair follicles—yes, yeast. Specifically Malassezia, which thrives in warm, humid environments (hi, sweaty workouts and occlusive moisturizers). These breakouts are usually small, uniform, slightly itchy bumps, often on your forehead, chest, or back. And here’s the kicker—treating it with acne products like benzoyl peroxide or retinoids can make it worse. What it really wants? An anti-fungal moment.

So before you hit your skin with another layer of exfoliant, let’s make sure you’re actually fighting the right enemy.

🔍 How to Tell the Difference (Symptoms + Visual Cues)

Okay, now that we know what causes each type of acne, let’s talk about how the heck to tell them apart. Because when you’re staring at your reflection trying to decode whether your skin hates your moisturizer or your menstrual cycle... it gets confusing fast.

The key? Location, texture, timing, and how your skin feels. Here’s your cheat sheet:

Feature Cystic Acne Hormonal Acne Fungal Acne
Depth Deep, under the skin Surface to deep Surface-level
Pain Very painful Mild to moderate pain Usually itchy, not painful
Appearance Large red nodules Red bumps, whiteheads Tiny uniform white bumps
Location Cheeks, jawline, chin Jawline, chin, mouth Forehead, chest, back
Timing Random or constant Cyclical (hello, periods) After sweating or antibiotics
Triggers Bacteria, excess oil Hormones (androgens) Yeast + humidity/sweat
Worsens with... Picking, rich creams Stress, hormone shifts Moisturizers, oils, occlusives

Still stuck? Here’s how to spot them in the wild:

  • If it’s painful, deep, and takes forever to heal—we’re likely in cystic territory.
  • If it flares up around your period or follows a hormonal pattern, especially along the jawline—it’s probably hormonal.
  • If it’s itchy, shows up in clusters, and lives on your forehead or chest—it could be fungal, especially if nothing else is working.
Smiling woman with a headband and under-eye patches, representing skincare and acne treatments for a beauty blog. Ideal for targeting acne-prone skin and boosting skincare routines.

💊 Best Treatments by Type (Backed by Science)

If you’ve ever emptied your bank account trying to nuke a breakout that just wouldn’t budge—only to make it worse—you’re not alone. The trick isn’t hitting your whole face with everything under your sink. It’s using the right treatment for the right acne. Let’s break it down by type so your skincare can stop guessing and start winning.

🧪 Cystic Acne: Deep, Painful, and Relentless

The fix: Anti-inflammatory, bacteria-killing, pore-clearing warriors.

  • Benzoyl Peroxide (BPO): Kills acne-causing bacteria and reduces inflammation. A clinical staple for a reason.
  • Topical Retinoids: These boost cell turnover and prevent clogged pores before they become cystic chaos. Think adapalene (Differin) or tretinoin (prescription).
  • Sulfur: Anti-inflammatory and anti-microbial, great for calming down angry skin without over-drying.

Derms may also prescribe oral antibiotics or isotretinoin (Accutane) for severe cases, but for home use, stick with these topicals:

Looking for more acne-fighting tips? Check out this post where we dive deep into retinoids—your best friend in the fight against cystic acne.

🧪 Hormonal Acne: When Your Skin Syncs With Your Cycle

The fix: Balance the hormones, reduce the oil, calm the inflammation.

  • Prescription MVPs: Spironolactone (anti-androgen) or birth control pills can help regulate hormonal swings from the inside.
  • Topical Support: Retinoids, salicylic acid, and niacinamide (which reduces oil and inflammation).
  • Supplements: Zinc, DIM (diindolylmethane), and spearmint tea show promise—but check with your doc.

Affiliate-worthy recs:

Hormonal acne got you down? Here’s how to balance your skin’s hydration and oil production to reduce breakouts.

🧪 Fungal Acne: The Sneaky Yeast Party You Didn’t RSVP To

The fix: Antifungals and a full-on oil cleanse (as in... remove the oils feeding the yeast, not add more).

  • Ketoconazole Shampoo: Use as a face + body wash 2–3x per week. Yes, really.
  • Zinc Pyrithione: Calms inflammation and targets yeast.
  • Avoid: Fatty acid–rich oils and occlusive moisturizers (looking at you, coconut oil and shea butter).

Safe + Effective Picks:

Want to know what actually works for fungal acne? This guide on pore-clearing ingredients will help you build the perfect routine.

Surprised woman wearing under-eye hydrogel patches on a yellow background, showcasing acne treatments and skincare solutions for clear, refreshed skin.

💥 Common Mistakes That Make Acne Worse

When it comes to acne, the best treatments are often sabotaged by a few common skincare slip-ups. Whether you’re over-exfoliating, playing mad scientist with your products, or letting stress run the show, these mistakes can make your acne angrier than a toddler on a sugar rush.

Let’s go through the worst offenders and how to avoid them:

1. Over-Exfoliating

Yes, exfoliating is essential for clearing out dead skin cells, but here’s the thing: too much exfoliation can do more harm than good. If your skin’s red, irritated, and flaky, you’ve likely stripped it of its protective barrier—and that just opens the door for more acne.

What to do: Stick to 2-3 times a week for chemical exfoliants like salicylic acid or glycolic acid. And always follow up with a moisturizer (trust me, your skin will thank you).

2. Using Harsh Scrubs

If you’re scrubbing your face like it’s a dirty pot, stop. Scrubs with rough exfoliating beads or crushed walnut shells can cause micro-tears in your skin, which leads to more inflammation and irritation. Plus, you're just pushing bacteria deeper into those pores. Yikes.

What to do: Ditch the physical scrubs. Opt for chemical exfoliants that dissolve dead skin without all the abrasive action.

3. Mixing Too Many Actives

I know it’s tempting to layer on every acne-fighting ingredient in your arsenal, but here’s the truth: your skin can only take so much. Mixing retinoids, benzoyl peroxide, and acids can overwhelm your skin and lead to redness, dryness, and yes—more breakouts.

What to do: Introduce actives one at a time and give your skin a break. Start with a retinoid at night, salicylic acid in the morning, and see how your skin reacts.

4. Not Moisturizing (Even With Oily Skin)

One of the biggest myths out there is that oily skin doesn’t need moisturizer. But skipping moisturizer can actually backfire—when your skin is dehydrated, it compensates by producing more oil. That can lead to clogged pores and even more breakouts.

What to do: Choose a non-comedogenic moisturizer with ingredients like hyaluronic acid or niacinamide that hydrate without clogging pores.

5. Using DIY Remedies (Like Lemon or Toothpaste)

Stop. Just... stop. DIY acne “treatments” like lemon juice, toothpaste, and honey masks might sound cute on Pinterest, but they can cause irritation, burns, or worse—worsen your acne.

What to do: Stick to science-backed treatments. There’s a reason your derm recommends ingredients like benzoyl peroxide, retinoids, and salicylic acid—they actually work.

6. Skipping SPF (Especially After Using Actives)

I know you’re probably thinking, “But I don’t need sunscreen indoors!” Guess what? You do. Even if you're not basking in the sun, UV rays still reach your skin and can make acne scars worse. Plus, using actives like retinoids and acids make your skin more sensitive to the sun.

What to do: Wear sunscreen daily (SPF 30 or higher) to protect your skin from further damage and help heal acne scars faster.

Once you’ve conquered acne, it’s time to tackle that dull skin! Here are 7 proven ways to bring back your glow after breakouts.

🏁 Final Takeaway & Call to Action

Alright, you’ve got the rundown. Now let’s wrap it up: acne doesn’t have to be a lifelong struggle. Whether you’re fighting cystic, hormonal, or fungal acne, understanding your skin and using the right treatments is half the battle. And the best part? With the right science-backed products, you’re already a step ahead in the fight against breakouts.

So, What’s Your Next Step?

  • Spot the culprit: Check your acne type (is it deep, painful, or itchy?)

  • Pick your fighter: Choose a treatment that actually works for what you’re dealing with. No more throwing random products at your skin!

  • Stay consistent: Acne treatments work over time, so be patient and consistent.

If you’re tired of guessing and want the proven science behind clear skin, it’s time to take action. I’ve linked the best products for each type of acne, so go ahead—treat yourself to what actually works. Because your skin deserves it, and honestly, so do you.

📚References

  1. Draelos, Z. D. (2005). "Sebum Control in Acne." Journal of Investigative Dermatology Symposium Proceedings, 10(3), 230–233.

  2. Lautenschlager, S., et al. (2006). "The UV Sunscreen Debate." Clinical Dermatology, 24(1), 62–76.

  3. Boo, Y. C. (2021). "Mechanistic Basis and Clinical Evidence for Nicotinamide (Niacinamide) in Controlling Skin Aging and Pigmentation." Antioxidants, 10(8), 1315.

  4. Zhang, X., et al. (2023). "Comprehensive Assessment of the Efficacy and Safety of a Clay Mask in Oily and Acne Skin." Skin Research and Technology, 29(11), 102-108.

  5. Wang, C., et al. (2019). "The Effect of Retinoids on Acne and Pore Size." Journal of Dermatology Research, 35(6), 45-58.

  6. Sharad, J. (2013). "Glycolic Acid Peel Therapy – A Current Review." Clinical, Cosmetic and Investigational Dermatology, 6, 45–55.

  7. Boo, Y. C. (2022). "Ascorbic Acid (Vitamin C) for Dermal Collagen and Anti-Aging." Antioxidants, 11(9), 1663.

  8. Kang, S., et al. (2005). "A Multicenter, Randomized, Double-Blind Trial of Tazarotene 0.1% Cream in the Treatment of Photodamage." Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology, 52(2), 183–190.

  9. Kim, J., et al. (2013). "Effects of Zinc and Other Mineral Ingredients in Barrier Repair." Clinical Cosmetology Investigations in Dermatology, 4, 135-142.

  10. Arif, T. (2015). "Salicylic Acid as a Peeling Agent: A Comprehensive Review." Clinical, Cosmetic and Investigational Dermatology, 8, 157–162.

Mollie Kelly Tufman
Previous

Can Sunscreen Actually Fade Dark Spots? Here’s What Studies Show
Next

🧬 Everything You’ve Heard About Peptides Might Be Wrong — Here’s What the Studies Say